Checkout psychology: why we trust some payment buttons more than others

You know the moment. The basket is full, the delivery slot is booked, and the page wants the long number from your card, its expiry date and the code from the back. The shop is one you found ten minutes ago on the Overground home. Your thumb hovers, until you spot a logo you recognise further down the screen.

Around 45.9 million people, or 80% of UK adults, bought goods or services online in 2025, according to UK Finance’s latest UK Payment Markets report. That moment of doubt has been measured. In a 2025 survey of 1,026 US adults by Baymard Institute, an independent web research institute in Denmark, 19% said they had abandoned a checkout in the previous three months because they “didn’t trust the site with their credit card information”.

A name you already know

A familiar payment button changes who you are being asked to trust. Instead of typing your card details into a stranger’s form, you approve the payment with a company you already use. To take an example from gambling, the third and final step of a deposit on a UK site that takes PayPal, an online casino for over-18s, is to log in to PayPal and approve the payment there.

Baymard’s researchers found that shoppers, having little technical understanding of how payment forms are secured, go by their “perceived sense of security”. That, they concluded, is shaped largely by how recognisable the site’s brand is and by the visual cues around the form. Wallet brands are everyday names for many adults: the same UK Finance report, published in August, found 89% of 25- to 34-year-olds were registered for mobile payments such as Apple Pay or Google Pay in 2025, against 29% of people aged 65 and over.

What sits behind the button

There is substance behind the feeling. PayPal says the recipient of a payment doesn’t receive sensitive financial details such as your card or bank account number. Apple says that when you use Apple Pay in an app or on the web, neither Apple nor your device sends your actual card number; the shop gets a device account number and a security code specific to that transaction.

Card payments have gained a check of their own. The Payment Services Regulations 2017 define strong customer authentication as using independent checks from at least two of three categories: something only you know, something only you hold and something inherent to you. The Financial Conduct Authority expected full compliance for online card payments by 14 March 2022, and banks such as TSB and Danske Bank may now ask you to approve a payment in their app or enter a one-time code sent by text.

The padlock problem

The padlock says less than it seems. Google has said the lock icon means the connection between your browser and a site can’t be tampered with or eavesdropped on, not that the site is trustworthy. Its 2021 research found only 11% of participants correctly understood what the icon meant, and Google points out that nearly all phishing sites display it too.

In May 2023 Google announced that Chrome would replace the padlock with a version of the “tune” icon, commonly used for controls and settings, from version 117, due that September. Baymard, meanwhile, counts padlock icons, effectively “meaningless” in its words, among the visual cues that can lift how secure a payment form feels.

Feeling safe versus being covered

Trust and protection are different things. The National Cyber Security Centre says many credit cards protect online purchases under the Consumer Credit Act, while debit cards give less protection, though a refund may be possible through the voluntary chargeback scheme. It also suggests checking what cover wallets such as PayPal, Apple Pay and Google Pay provide. PayPal’s Buyer Protection says it will help you get a full refund on eligible purchases if an item doesn’t arrive or isn’t as the seller described.

If a checkout proves fake, where to report it changed last December. Report Fraud, run by the City of London Police, the Square Mile’s force and the national lead force for fraud and cyber crime, replaced Action Fraud on 4 December 2025.

Back on the Overground, that familiar logo has worked like the visual cues Baymard describes, lending a stranger’s checkout some of its reputation. Recognition makes a button feel safe; a glance at the web address and a minute with the terms are what make that trust well placed.

You must be 18 or over to play. If gambling stops being fun, the National Gambling Helpline (0808 8020 133) is free and open 24/7, and GAMSTOP lets you block every UK-licensed gambling site at once.

Loading...